Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Reflection on Assignment 2

In Assignment 2, I chose to review a course using the Quality Matters rubric. I specifically chose the first option for Assignment 2 because I thought about obtaining the Quality Matters certification before I started my program here at UMUC. Because of this, I was very interested in exploring the rubric in more detail and also reading the Quality Matters literature. I found both the assignment and the rubric to be very beneficial for me, especially as it relates to my profession as an Instructional Designer.

Overall, OMDE 603 scored very well. As I stated in the assignment, sadly, the lowest scored areas were the Learner Support and Accessibility areas which are both critical in the online learning environment. One of the most interesting aspects of this assignment was discovering that the Accessibility standards scored low. I find this interesting because, in my experience, I think that this is a universal problem in online courses. I guess because I don’t have any accessibility issues, I have never paid much attention to the accessibility items in any of the courses that I’ve taken at UMUC. Since I work on online courses by day, however, issues regarding accessibility are frequently discussed. In my professional experience, I’ve found that the institutions that I’ve worked for want courses developed for the masses. As the few students with accessibility issues complain, someone in another department, outside of product development, handles these issues. This doesn’t seem logical to me. If certain accessibility options were built into courses on the front-end then this scrambling for a particular student after a course has been launched wouldn’t be necessary.

My personal takeaways from this assignment include the following:

Ø  The Quality Matters rubric provides detailed standards regarding the elements that must be in the online classroom in order to effectively support students.
Ø  The rubric can be used at the beginning of the course development process when designing and structuring course content and/or at the end of the course development process to ensure that all standards have been met.
Ø  In my opinion, the Quality Matters rubric is more learner-focused than instructor-focused.
Ø  The lack of accessibility options for students in need seems to be a universal problem in online courses
Ø  I think that an additional item or standard should be added to the rubric that focuses on student preparation. As I stated in the assignment, one of the best attributes of OMDE 603 was that the discussion questions for each week were listed in the Syllabus. This allowed me to stay moderately ahead of the coursework while juggling a busy schedule.

Saturday, February 25, 2012

Spring Cleaning

After reading this week’s article by Lee and McLoughlin, I realized that I need to add something to my spring cleaning list…organize my many lists of social technology sites. Unfortunately, I have absolutely no current system for maintaining and storing my list of websites, both for personal and professional uses. As I stated in this week’s Discussion forum, the many social technology tool websites are overwhelming. I find myself haphazardly writing names of websites on post-its, sending emails to myself with the names of websites, and writing notes about websites in my phone. Very disjointed. I attended a webinar earlier this week, titled “Discovery, Discussion, and Demonstration”, about social technology tools and the presenter listed several sites in three different categories---discovery, discussion, and demonstration, hence the title.
Shortly after I got home from work, I read Lee and McLoughlin’s article, paying close attention to Table 4.1, and realized that this table was just another reminder of my own disorganization when it comes to keeping track of the technology tools that I use and the sites that I’d like to visit and explore. The authors, Lee and McLoughlin, separate social networking tools into the following categories: “Connectivity and social rapport”, “Collaborative information discovery and sharing”, “Content creation”, and “Knowledge and information aggregation and content modification”.
For my personal and professional purposes, I think that I will use both a combination of Lee and McLoughlin’s categories and the categories from the webinar. I’ve decided to divide my own catalog of sites into the following: Social Networks, Discovery and Sharing, and Content Creation and Modification. These categories should help me to effectively manage the many sites that I visit on a regular basis and organize the new sites that I want to visit. Now, on to cataloging…

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Quality Improvement

My favorite resource this week was Sangra, Guardia, and Gonzalez-Sanmamed’s “Educational Design as a Key Issue in Planning for Quality Improvement”. This chapter addressed the most frustrating aspect of online learning and instructional design, for me professionally, which is the importance of learner feedback in order to improve the instructional design of a course. This topic is frustrating to me because in my current position, I don’t have access to student feedback and we definitely don’t have any sort of scorecard similar to the balanced scorecard for methodology that the Universitat Oberta de Catalunyal uses to assess the effectiveness of the learning process. I totally agree with the authors that “Improvement in the instructional design can become one of the most effective strategies to achieve better results in the teaching and learning process, in terms of academic performance as students’ perceptions of their own satisfaction with respect to what they achieve and how they meet the objectives set” (p. 294). I believe that this opportunity for “improvement in the instructional design” is vital to the success of a course, program, and the online learning field as a whole. In order to improve, we must know what needs to be improved and adjusted to accommodate learners. Also, because online learning is a fairly new element of distance learning, we in the field, need to know what works and what doesn’t. How can that be discovered without some sort of formal process that online providers can use to effectively assess course design?
Reference:
Sangra, A., Guardia, L., & Gonzalez - Sanmamed, M. (2007). Educational design as a key issue in planning for quality improvement. In M. Bullen & D. Janes (Eds.), Making the transition to e-learning (pp. 284 - 299). Hershey, Pa, USA: Information Science Publishing. 

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Conrad's "The Plain Hard Work of Teaching Online"

Conrad’s chapter was a very interesting read. This chapter made me gain a better understanding of the qualities that an effective online instructor should possess. Although Conrad’s 5 C’s—community, collaboration, communication, collegiality, and commitment--make perfect sense and are necessary elements of a successful classroom experience, some of Conrad’s other views seem easier said than done. Conrad suggests that online teachers should think of imaginative ways to appeal to online students, in order to maintain their engagement. This is a great point. I think that maintaining student engagement in the course content is one of, if not the, most important aspects of the online learning environment. I think that this can be achieved by ensuring that the course content is fresh and thought-provoking and making sure that the content is presented in a variety of ways…i.e. text, media, discussion questions, etc.

Conrad also discusses attitudes that online instructors should have. This includes the ability to “embark on a very different adventure that demands re-examination of both assumptions and practices” (p. 200). Conrad also states that online instructors should rethink “…their curriculum and their pedagogy but also their presentation, their sense of instructional ‘self’, and their personalities” (p.200). Although I agree that online instructors should have these attitudes, I wonder if this notion of reexamining one’s entire teaching practice and even personality is realistic for most online instructors. I wonder about the traditional instructors who are pushed into the online direction and who maybe have little interest in changing or updating their teaching practices. This made me think…should instructors be expected to reevaluate their practices to accommodate the online environment OR should only those instructors who are naturally flexible, open to teaching practices that are conducive to the online environment, and who possess the “right” personality for an online learning environment move to (or stay in) the online environment? I’ve personally taken classes with online instructors who don’t seem too happy to be there, but I’m not sure if that was just who they were as an instructor or if they just felt a bit out of place online. Regardless of which one it is, I think that every institution that offers online courses should not only have formal standards for their courses, but also for their instructors…and maybe they should adopt some of their standards from Conrad’s views.

Reference:

Conrad, D. (2007). The plain hard work of teaching online. In M. Bullen & D. Janes (Eds.), Making the transition to e-learning (pp. 191-207). Hershey, PA: Information Science Publishing. 

Friday, February 10, 2012

The First Assignment

Topic 1-Have you developed a theory of online teaching and learning based on your own experience as a student? If so, how does that theory guide your approach to learning and affect your practices as a student?
Topic 2-What is theory and how does it affect our understanding of things or actions in life? Do you think learning theory has a potential benefit for faculty and for you as a student? If so, what is that possible benefit and how have you experienced or observed that benefit? 
I chose to address Topic 2 for the first paper. I decided to delve into this particular topic primarily because, as I’ve made clear in my reflection from February 3rd, I have never really thought much about my personal philosophy when it comes to online teaching and learning. To my surprise, completing my paper for Topic 2 not only helped me enhance my thoughts regarding the benefits of theory, but also helped me carve out my personal philosophy a little bit more. In my paper, I discussed the following two important benefits of theory--- theory informs us of what has already been discovered and theory prepares us for the future of online learning.
My strong attraction to connectivist theory definitely has some relation to my opinion that theory prepares us for the future. Upon reading about connectivist theory in Ally’s “Foundations of Educational Theory for Online Learning”, I immediately thought that this school of learning is the future of online learning. Fully understanding the elements of this theory can certainly help us as learners and educators understand the characteristics that will will need to know and teach to remain relevant in the future of education. The most important characteristics, in my opinion, are 1) the ability to be flexible in terms of learning materials, concepts, and ideas and 2) the capacity to learn new information quickly and unlearn old information quickly.

When I read about Ally’s behaviorist school of learning, I immediately thought of this theory as the foundation or the basics of online learning. This school relates to my other benefit-- theory informs us of what has already been discovered. I think that the characteristics of this school of learning have been proven to provide students with a beneficial learning environment.

For example, Ally states, “Learners should be told the explicit outcomes of the learning so they can set expectations…” (p. 20).

“Learners must be tested to determine whether or not they have achieved the learning outcome” (p.21).

“The learning materials must be sequenced appropriately to promote learning” (p.21).

“Learners must be provided with feedback so that they can monitor how they are doing and take corrective action if required” (p.21).All of these items serve as the basis for an online course. The absence of one or more of them would undoubtedly affect the student’s ability to learn and develop throughout the duration of the course.

Reference:
Ally, M. (2008). Foundations of educational theory for online learning. In T. Anderson (Ed.), The Theory and practice of online learning (2nd ed.) pp. 15-49. Athabasca, CA: Athabasca University Press.

Friday, February 3, 2012

My Personal Philosophy

This week, I had what can best be described as an “Aha moment” when reading Kanuka’s chapter, “Understanding E-learning Technologies in Practice through Philosophies in Practice”. This chapter discusses the philosophies of technology and practice in detail. Kanuka states, “…when we are aware of the philosophies of teaching and technology, we can then articulate our own personal philosophy. Knowing our personal philosophy helps us to understand why we act and think the way we do about using e-learning technologies, as well as why others think and act the way they do about e-learning technologies” (p. 93).

Aha, this makes sense! I’ve never once thought about MY personal philosophy when it comes to e-learning. I’ve been immersed in the e-learning field through work and school for four years now and have been so focused on the popular theories in the field…so much so that I’ve failed to reflect on what I believe. When I think about what compelled me to come back to school, it was because I wanted formal education in the world of e-learning, not just on-the-job training. I was effectively completing my work responsibilities, as an Online Product Specialist, on a daily basis, but I didn’t know why I was doing certain things. I didn’t have a solid foundation of knowledge about the e-learning field and that’s why I’m here today.

In thinking about my personal philosophy, which has been a little more challenging than I expected, I think that my philosophy is a loose combination of a couple of different philosophies.

The Progressive philosophy speaks to me because I enjoy learning through experimental and situational approaches and I think that using these approaches can provide a wealth of practical knowledge to students. I also like the idea of the Humanist philosophy because of its emphasis on learner growth and “self-directed learning”.  Although, one thing about this philosophy that confuses me is that it's based on the idea of individual growth, but relies heavily on group work. Looking at the other philosophies, I'm not sure how my beliefs fit into their models.

One of my goals in this course will be to further explore my personal philosophy and revisit this topic in the coming weeks.

Reference:


Kanuka, H. (2008). Understanding e-learning technologies in practice through philosophies in practice. In T. Anderson (Ed.), The Theory and practice of online learning (2nd Ed.) pp. 91-120. Athabasca, CA: Athabasca University Press.